My hackles rose when Sam said "No, it isn't" and when he and Dean insisted on calling her Annie. But then, Sam was the one who switched to calling her Alex as soon as she started engaging with them, so I kind of forgave him? (I might be prone to forgiving Sam rather easily. /obvious)

I had similar thoughts about Dean playing possum, and how long he'd been doing so.

I liked Dean's line to Sam because it was so dysfunctional. What I didn't like: the way Sam questioned him on his behavior. That didn't ring true for me. Because, yeah, nothing new in terms of Dean taking pleasure in killing. That scene seemed like (ineffectual) shorthand.

The rest of the episode really worked for me. ♥ ♥ Jody! ♥ ♥ This was the best Jody episode yet, IMO.